The Timeline

Two decades, one closed door

Every date below is drawn directly from council minutes, agenda items, utility filings, and public reporting — cited at each entry. This is the film's working chronology, not a dramatization.

  1. 1974Context

    Austin locks into the Fayette coal plant

    Austin Energy signs on as a joint owner of the Fayette Power Project — an agreement that, as written, leaves the city unable to unilaterally reduce its share or exit the plant, regardless of what it costs later.

    Source: Secret Vote research index — financial-pattern analysis
  2. 2008Context

    A 20-year, $2.3 billion biomass contract

    Austin Energy signs a two-decade biomass power contract. It will later have to be bought out for $460 million once cheap natural gas makes it uncompetitive — and the plant sits idle during Winter Storm Uri.

    Source: Secret Vote research index — financial-pattern analysis
  3. 2009Context

    Webberville solar deal locked in at ~16.5¢/kWh

    A solar power-purchase agreement locks in a rate several times higher than utility-scale solar costs today — a reminder that long-duration energy contracts cut both ways, not only toward gas.

    Source: Secret Vote research index — financial-pattern analysis
  4. March 2020The Reversal

    Austin promises, in writing, to stop building gas

    The Resource, Generation and Climate Protection Plan to 2030 commits Austin Energy to retiring its share of the Fayette coal plant by the end of 2022, closing Decker's steam units within two years, and retiring all remaining Decker/Sand Hill gas units by 2035 — replaced by solar, demand response, storage, wind, and nuclear. “No new thermal (gas) generation included in the replacement mix.”

    Source: Sierra Club, March 2020 →
  5. October 2020Context

    Decker's first steam unit retires, on schedule

    Decker Unit 1 goes offline roughly on the timeline the 2020 plan promised.

    Source: Secret Vote research index — Retirement/Replacement Timeline
  6. February 2021Context

    Winter Storm Uri

    ERCOT — the state grid operator, not Austin Energy — orders rotating outages statewide. More than 40% of Austin Energy's own customers lose power. The utility's own plants mostly stay online, and Austin Energy sells the surplus onto the statewide grid at storm prices — an estimated $54 million net gain.

    Source: KUT and Community Impact, March 9, 2021; Austin Energy wholesale cost reporting
  7. End of 2022The Reversal

    The Fayette deadline is missed

    The coal plant's promised retirement date passes. It keeps running.

    Source: Texas Tribune, October 2023 →
  8. 2022Context

    Decker's second steam unit retires

    Between the two Decker retirements, Austin Energy takes roughly 725 megawatts — about 45% of its local generation capacity — offline.

    Source: Secret Vote research index — Retirement/Replacement Timeline
  9. March 2023Context

    General Manager Jackie Sargent steps down

    Sargent, the GM when the 2020 no-new-gas plan passed, leaves office.

    Source: Austin Monitor, March 2023 →
  10. July 2023Context

    Bob Kahn, former ERCOT president, becomes GM

    Kahn — previously president and CEO of ERCOT itself — takes over as Austin Energy's general manager, four months before the utility's modeling reverses the no-new-gas commitment.

    Source: Secret Vote research index
  11. August 17, 2023Context

    Fayette earns $11 million in a single day

    Austin Energy's own reporting cites a single day of ERCOT ancillary-service revenue from the still-running Fayette plant — money a spokesperson says would otherwise have landed on customer rates if the plant had retired on schedule.

    Source: Texas Tribune, October 2023 →
  12. September 2023The Alternatives

    “Explore a solar battery storage program”

    Austin Energy briefs its own oversight commission on battery storage in exploratory language only — while Texas's statewide battery fleet is already growing by gigawatts a year, Austin Energy has no grid-scale battery project of its own yet underway.

    Source: Austin Energy briefing, Sept 2023 (edims doc id 415622)
  13. November 13, 2023The Reversal

    The model that reverses the promise

    Austin Energy's Resource Generation Plan Update models eleven portfolio scenarios. The recommended option — a locally sited, hydrogen-capable gas portfolio — is modeled to cost roughly $1 billion a year less than continuing an all-renewables path. This is the single internal financial model that undoes the 2020 commitment. It was never rerun before the 2026 vote.

    Source: Austin Energy Resource Generation Plan Update, Nov 2023 →
  14. December 12, 2024The Alternatives

    Council adopts a new 2035 goal — and promises to show its work

    Council votes 11-0 for a new “100% carbon-free by 2035” plan. Two amendments are added the same day, also 11-0: a commitment to 125MW of battery storage by end of 2027 “if economically feasible” and an all-resource RFP before pursuing peakers (Qadri, Velásquez); and a promise to show, before any peaker approval, “any analysis performed demonstrating why a carbon-free alternative was not available” (Alter).

    Source: Council transcript & minutes, Dec 12, 2024
  15. February 3, 2025The Alternatives

    Austin Energy issues its only dedicated Battery RFP

    Austin Energy opens a Request for Proposals dedicated solely to battery storage — the only resource-specific RFP Austin Energy runs this cycle for a single technology. It will go on to produce three separate contracts (Jupiter Power, Base Power, and a second Jupiter Power deal). No equivalent dedicated RFP is ever issued for gas.

    Source: AEUOC Resource, Generation and Climate Protection Plan update, agenda backup presentation, Jul 22, 2025 (RFP issued Feb 3, 2025); EUC “Implementation Progress Milestones” backup, May 11, 2026
  16. July 24, 2025The Alternatives

    First battery contract awarded — approved on consent, in public

    Council approves a battery tolling agreement with Balcones Ridge Resiliency, a Jupiter Power subsidiary, for up to 100MW, up to $14.4M a year, $288M over 20 years — on the consent agenda, 11-0. It's the first award out of February's dedicated Battery RFP.

    Source: Council minutes, Jul 24, 2025, Item 16
  17. October 23, 2025The Process

    First attempt to close the door — withdrawn

    A closed-session item on Austin Energy generation resources is placed on the agenda, then withdrawn before any vote.

    Source: Council minutes, Oct 23, 2025, Item 67
  18. October 2025Context

    Stuart Reilly is promoted to General Manager

    Reilly — Kahn's own deputy general manager for business services, and one of the people in the room for the December 2024 plan — is promoted into the top job seven months before he presides over the May 2026 closed-door vote himself.

    Source: Community Impact, Oct 2025 →
  19. November 2025The Alternatives

    The one RFP gas ever competed in

    Austin Energy launches its broad, catch-all All-Resource RFP — four months after Jupiter Power's dedicated-RFP deal was already before Council. It draws 7 battery proposals and, for the first and only time, 5 gas proposals. No solar bids. Gas is not selected; Austin Energy later tells the EUC it didn't want to “limit the vendor pool... to the vendors that are comfortable with their numbers being public,” and pivots straight to private manufacturer talks instead — no dedicated gas RFP ever follows.

    Source: EUC backup presentation, May 11, 2026 (All-Resource RFP results & Implementation Progress Milestones); EUC meeting transcript, May 11, 2026
  20. December 11, 2025The Process

    Second attempt — and a warning on the record

    “We are very concerned about the conversation that took place in November about rushing to put a deposit on gas peakers... None of this has been done,” Kaiba White of Public Citizen tells council, quoting its own December 2024 promise back to it. The closed-session item is withdrawn again the same day.

    Source: Council transcript, Dec 11, 2025
  21. May 11, 2026The Alternatives

    A citizen commissioner makes the case against, in public

    At the Electric Utility Commission, citizen commissioner Al Braden presents Austin Energy's own cost figures against the deal: an estimated $200 million-plus for peakers “intended to run as little as possible,” and a pointed finding — if ERCOT is seriously constrained in an emergency, ERCOT dictates allocation regardless of who owns the plant. “How can this investment be financially justified?”

    Source: Al Braden, “Gas Peakers” EUC presentation, May 11, 2026
  22. May 11, 2026The Alternatives

    The all-resource RFP's one battery winner

    The same Electric Utility Commission meeting where Al Braden challenges the peaker deal also carries Austin Energy's recommendation to negotiate a battery storage agreement with OCI Energy — up to 100MW, up to $8.25M a year, $165M over 20 years. It's the only battery contract to come out of the broad All-Resource RFP; the other battery awards (Jupiter Power, Base Power) trace back to February 2025's dedicated Battery RFP instead.

    Source: EUC agenda backup, May 11, 2026, Item 6
  23. May 19, 2026The Alternatives

    A third RFP-sourced battery deal, also approved in the open

    Austin Energy finalizes a battery tolling agreement with Base Power for up to 40MW of residential-scale capacity — another award from February 2025's dedicated Battery RFP, not the all-resource one. Full system capacity is expected by mid-to-late 2027. It's approved two days before the closed-door gas vote.

    Source: Austin Energy EUC agenda backup, Item 8, Apr 13, 2026 (“In February 2025, Austin Energy issued a Request for Proposals (RFP)... This battery tolling agreement with Base Power... result[s] from this RFP”); RCA File #26-1526; AE news release, May 19, 2026
  24. May 21, 2026 — the voteThe Vote

    Withdrawn in public. Approved behind closed doors.

    Item 7 — the public hearing on the new gas peaker plant — is pulled from the routine approval list for its own separate hearing. That hearing never happens. Final disposition: “Withdrawn. No motion. No second. No discussion. No vote.” That same afternoon, at 3:55 PM, Item 82 — a closed executive session citing “competitive matters” — is “conducted and approved,” with no recorded return to open session. Council Members Natasha Harper-Madison (District 1, whose district has hosted every one of Austin Energy's existing peaker units) and Vanessa Fuentes (District 2) are both absent for the entire meeting.

    Source: Austin City Council agenda & minutes, May 21, 2026 →
  25. May 28, 2026Accountability

    A week later, the council writes rules for a deal it never watched itself make

    Four resolutions respond to the closed-door approval: emissions and run-time caps (Siegel), construction/neighborhood-impact mitigation (Alter), a siting-justice measure naming Austin's “Eastern Crescent” and barring new peakers from being sited “solely... east of I-35” (Velásquez), and expanded EV-charging and battery programs (Qadri). KUT's own headline calls it a “secret vote.”

    Source: KUT, May 29, 2026 →
  26. July 23, 2026The Alternatives

    A second Jupiter Power contract, again approved in the open

    Jupiter Power's Balcones Ridge Resiliency II — a second, larger battery project, 200MW, up to $16M a year, $320M over 20 years — is approved 10-0, Council Member Fuentes absent. It's Jupiter's second battery contract with Austin Energy in a year; February 2025's RFP materials referenced a “second potential battery contract” under discussion with the same top proposers, though no document explicitly names this deal's RFP source. It lands right around what Austin Energy's own 2023 model assumed battery costs would be — unlike the gas side of the ledger.

    Source: Council agenda, Item 6, July 23, 2026 →
  27. 2026, after the voteAccountability

    The general manager's public defense

    “Solar and wind alone cannot address the risks we face during extreme weather... Battery storage is improving rapidly, but it cannot yet replace the need for power that can start instantly and run as long as necessary.” — Stuart Reilly, General Manager. Made publicly, after the vote, not before it.

    Source: Austin Energy news release, 2026 →
  28. As of filmingContext

    What's still not public

    The exact terms of the peaker contract — vendor, final site, signed price — have not been released. The widely cited “~$1 billion” figure is a reporter's estimate; Austin Energy has declined to confirm it.

    Source: Secret Vote production notes